Science Media Centre spins the pause
Jul 22, 2013
Bishop Hill in Climate: Models, Climate: Surface, Science Media Centre

The Science Media Centre is best known to readers here for its press release about the Oxburgh inquiry, in which they managed to quote only scientists implicated in wrongdoing over Climategate.

Today the centre has released a statement on the failure of global temperatures to rise in line with the models. It can be seen here.

It's spin of course, although perhaps not quite as blatant as we are used to from Fiona Fox et al. As one might expect there's a lot of emphasis on natural variability and not a lot on why the observations are on the cusp of falling out of the uncertainty bands. Lots of "our understanding is getting better" and not a lot of "nobody has a clue what's going on".

There's a complete misrepresentation of science's level of understanding of the reasons why this is happening:

It is becoming increasingly clear that absorption of heat in deep oceans is part of the explanation.

I think what they mean is that this is a somewhat implausible post-hoc rationalisation of the failure of the models to conform to reality; perhaps the copyeditor missed it.

As I said in Parliament, the inability of climate scientists to admit their ignorance is one of the reasons nobody trusts them. The Science Media Centre are just helping that process along in the wrong direction.

Update on Jul 22, 2013 by Registered CommenterBishop Hill

Lucia tweets out that the SMC's remarks about climate sensitivity make no sense:

"we are becoming more confident of mid-range figures." why not 'mid-range or lower?

Update on Jul 22, 2013 by Registered CommenterBishop Hill

David Shukman's take is here.

...the scientists say, pauses in warming were always to be expected. This is new - at least to me.

It is common sense that climate change would not happen in a neat, linear away but instead in fits and starts.

But I've never heard leading researchers mention the possibility before.

Article originally appeared on (http://www.bishop-hill.net/).
See website for complete article licensing information.